top of page

China Shopping Mall Traffic and Sales Diverge: Rethinking the Brand Counter

Nov 5
5 min read

Key Takeaways


  • Winshang monitored 5% growth in average daily mall visits in H1 2026. This is a separate series from the CCFA enterprise survey. Source

  • A CCFA survey of 53 companies covering 1,978 operating malls found weighted average per-project sales growth of 3.6%, below footfall growth of 5.7%. Source

  • Among retail enterprises above the designated size, January-August convenience-store and supermarket sales rose 5.5% and 3.8%; specialty-store, department-store and mono-brand-store sales fell 2.2%, 3.0% and 10.0%. Source

  • Beauty store adjustments highlight the need to distinguish reported closures, estimates and confirmed company strategy.

  • Location, tenant mix and operating capability matter at the project level. City tier alone is insufficient for underwriting a store.



More visits do not necessarily deliver proportionately more sales. A CCFA survey of 53 companies covering 1,978 operating malls found weighted average per-project footfall growth of 5.7% in H1 2026, against sales growth of 3.6%. These are survey results, not a census of all Chinese malls. The gap calls for investigation of basket value, category mix, promotions and conversion, rather than an assumption that every additional visit should justify higher rent. Source



Exterior of Xidan Joy City in Beijing, photographed in August 2020
Xidan Joy City, Beijing, August 2020. Archival illustration of a shopping mall. (Source: N509FZ / Wikimedia Commons; CC BY-SA 4.0; unchanged.) Original: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Xidan_Joy_City_(20200827130958).jpg; License: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/

What Does the China Shopping Mall Traffic Data Show?


Winshang reported a 2.4% year-on-year fall in nationwide mall traffic in May 2026. The H1 average therefore masks variation within the period. Identifying a turning point requires a consistent monthly series, rather than inference from a half-year average. Source


Winshang monitored average daily traffic of 15,100 visits per mall in H1, up 5%. This differs from the 5.7% in the CCFA enterprise survey and should not be combined into one series. Spring Festival and policy support boosted first-quarter activity, but the available evidence does not establish that they accounted for almost all first-half growth. Source


For brands, aggregate retail supply is no substitute for project quality. The relevant questions concern the catchment, customer profile and actual performance of comparable tenants.



Why Do Shoppers Show Up and Spend Less?


January-August retail sales totalled RMB 32.76 trillion, up 1.1%. August grew 0.4% year on year and fell 0.13% month on month after seasonal adjustment. The retail-format breakdown covers enterprises above the designated size; it cannot be treated as the performance of a particular mall category or beauty counter. Source


Pressure on mono-brand stores gives brands a reason to reassess what makes a visit worthwhile. Experience, service and immediate fulfilment may help, but no category should be assumed immune to online competition.


Premium retail also requires analysis by category and customer group. Global luxury-group results and sales at individual Chinese malls are different measures; one cannot directly establish the other.



Why Is Beauty Leaving the Ground Floor?


Beauty-channel adjustments deserve attention, with care to distinguish estimates from comprehensive market data. A media report quotes a practitioner estimating that beauty’s share of ground-floor tenancies in Beijing core malls fell from about 35% to 22% over two years. It also cites a user’s public-map POI estimate of 30,627 operating counters and stores across a sample of 200 beauty brands in May 2026, down about 3.9% year on year and 15.4% from the sample’s Q3 2023 peak. Neither figure is an official national census. Source


Media reported that Lancôme’s Beijing Wangfujing apm flagship closed in August 2026. The suggestion that an online sales share above 50% prompted the closure came from a person close to the brand, rather than a confirmed company explanation. The reported deregistration of a Shiseido entity and 77 branches should not be equated with the closure of the same number of physical stores. Source


China Business Herald reported in June 2026 that, after its Sanlitun closure, Harmay had 26 stores in 13 cities, more than half opened since 2025. That is a dated snapshot combining older-store adjustment with new openings, rather than proof of continuous network contraction. Source



Dior beauty counter at Pangdonglai department store in Xinxiang, photographed in February 2023
Dior counter at Pangdonglai department store, Xinxiang, February 2023. Archival illustration of the counter format, not evidence of changes at this store. (Source: Windmemories / Wikimedia Commons; CC BY-SA 4.0; unchanged.) Original: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:20230217_Dior_Cosmetics_Store_at_DL_Department_Store_in_Xinxiang.jpg; License: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/

Why Are Some Malls Still Growing?


Winshang identifies outlets, premium malls and city-level malls in higher-tier markets as stronger asset types. “City-level” describes a project’s catchment role, not the tier of its city. The counts within these classifications are not a count of all growing malls. Source


Outlets also vary by project. The format label does not guarantee performance: brands still need to examine repeat demand, tenant access and operating capability.


Premium malls need both destination brands and a broader customer base that supports everyday trading. For a prospective tenant, fit with its price point and purchase frequency matters more than the premium label alone.


Regional and community malls need a clear point of difference. Where nearby projects offer similar tenant lineups, brands should compare customer profiles, circulation and category-level sales rather than rely on leasing presentations.


Lower-tier markets are not automatically better opportunities. The question is whether a project serves recurring local demand and offers brands or experiences that nearby competitors cannot easily replicate.


According to data supplied by Xidan Joy City, traffic rose 7% and sales 5% year on year in the first three quarters of 2026. Second-floor traffic rose nearly 40% month on month in the month the bridge connection opened. These comparison periods must remain distinct. The case supports examining circulation and floor positioning without attributing the whole result to one intervention. Source



What Should a Brand Recalculate Before Signing a Lease?


First, model traffic, conversion and basket value together. As an illustration, with consistent definitions and all other factors equal, 20,000 daily visits at 1% conversion imply 200 transactions; 12,000 at 2.5% imply 300. These are hypothetical figures, not observed projects. Ask for category sales density, occupancy costs and traffic definitions before judging a lease.


Second, assess the project before relying on city tier. Catchment reach, local competition and purchasing power require separate checks. A leading mall in a smaller city may offer an opportunity, but does not necessarily outperform a regional mall in a tier-one city.


Third, define the store’s job. Skin testing, treatments, refill services and customisation can be tested, but their effect on repeat purchase and profitability requires store-level evidence. The opportunities discussed in our analysis of China’s soap revival likewise depend on customer demand and experience, rather than a claim that online commerce has replaced every display-led store. Source


Fourth, plan around the project’s actual holiday and weekday patterns. Higher average holiday footfall does not mean every brand should launch during a long holiday. Weigh customer fit, campaign costs and transaction quality. Where the catchment includes international visitors, inbound tourism can provide an additional planning calendar. Source


Whether rent is justified depends on a specific building, tenant mix and customer base. Footfall is a starting point; brands also need to measure store entry, purchases, repeat visits and contribution per transaction.


Keep the lease model current. Store services, merchandise and occupancy costs should be reassessed against actual trading, rather than the original traffic projection.


China shopping mall traffic requires continued monitoring. The practical priority for brands is to connect those signals to store-level economics. The same question underlies Sephora’s China channel adjustment: what distinctive value does the store provide alongside e-commerce? Source



Double V is a cross-border operating partner and intelligence house for emerging consumer brands, based in Hong Kong and Shenzhen. We help brands connect China and the world through three businesses: Brand Operation (marketing and distribution for brands on retainer), Brand Incubation (sister company Glam Infinite and our own-built brands), and Industry Intelligence (cross-border research and reports). Talk to our team


Comments


bottom of page